top of page

Order Online

Accepting Orders
Pickup time: Oct 2, 2:00 PM - 5:00 PM
Pickup Address: 453 West 16th Street, Erie, PA 16502-1702

Cookies

Italian Almond Cookies

Almond flour cookies

$11.99

Italian Almond Cookies

Italian Almond Tea Cakes

Description

$20.99

Italian Almond Tea Cakes

Italian Knots

Iced Italian knot cookies with sprinkles

$9.99

Italian Knots

Ricotta Cheese Pie

Traditional Easter dessert made with Ricotta cheese, eggs, sugar, vanilla.

$21.99

Ricotta Cheese Pie

Fig-filled Knots

Fig/nut filled knot cookies

$17.50

Fig-filled Knots

Ricotta Cookies

Soft vanilla ricotta cookies

$8.99

Ricotta Cookies

White Wine Cookies

Egg-free wine cookies

$8.99

 White Wine Cookies

Biscotti - Cappuccino

Espresso biscotti

$10.99

Biscotti - Cappuccino

Biscotti - Anise

Classic anise biscotti

$12.99

Biscotti - Anise

Biscotti - Chocolate Cherry

Biscotti with chocolate, cherry, orange peel

$7.99

Biscotti - Chocolate Cherry

Pizzelles

Thin crisp cookies

$6.99

 Pizzelles
Featured

Peach cookies

Two basic dough cookies with a peach jam filling, dipped in liquor and rolled in sugar. They are topped off with a peach leaf making them look like you just picked it from a peach tree.

$21.50

Peach cookies
Featured

Lemon Cookies

Two basic dough cookies with a cream cheese/lemon curd filling, dipped in liquor and rolled in sugar. Topped off with a leaf to make a beautiful lemon!

$0.00

Lemon Cookies

Cakes

Italian Love Cake

Lemon or chocolate

$34.99

 Italian Love Cake

Apple Cake

Classic apple cake

$34.99

 Apple Cake

Lemon Loaf

Lemon loaf cake

$6.99

Lemon Loaf

Rum Cake

A Double layer sponge cake with Espresso & Rum drizzled on each layer.  Three layers (2 vanilla & 1 chocolate) of homemade pastry cream.  Frosted with a non-dairy frosting.

$69.99

Rum Cake

Peanut Butter Pie

$16.99

 Peanut Butter Pie

Nutella Pie

$16.99

Nutella Pie

Gluten Free

Apple Cake (GF/DF/SF)

Apple cake dietary-friendly

$14.99

 Apple Cake (GF/DF/SF)

Protein Balls

Energy snacks Batch (approximately 12-15)

$20.99

 Protein Balls

White Wine Cookies

$8.99

 White Wine Cookies

Amaretti

Almond cookies

$11.99

Amaretti

Seasonal

Ricotta Pie

Traditional pie

$21.99

 Ricotta Pie

Nut Rolls

$11.99

Nut Rolls

Weekly Menu

Italian Almond Cookies

Almond flour cookies

$11.99

Italian Almond Cookies

Italian Love Cake

Lemon or chocolate

$34.99

 Italian Love Cake

Nutella Pie

$16.99

Nutella Pie

Wedding/Specials

Cookies are sold in boxes of 12 dozen, which serves 50 people for $120 per box. It is recommended to choose 3-4 kinds from the list.

Cookie Box

Serves 50 people

$119.99

Italian Knots

Iced Italian knot cookies with sprinkles

$9.99

Italian Knots

Fig-filled Knots

Fig/nut filled knot cookies

$17.50

 Fig-filled Knots

Biscotti - Cappuccino

Espresso biscotti

$10.99

 Biscotti - Cappuccino

Biscotti - Anise

Classic anise biscotti

$12.99

 Biscotti - Anise

Biscotti - Chocolate Cherry

Biscotti with chocolate, cherry, orange peel

$7.99

 Biscotti - Chocolate Cherry

Fried Bow Ties

Fried dough with powdered sugar

$6.50

 Fried Bow Ties

Amaretti

Almond cookies

$11.99

 Amaretti

Rugelach

$9.99

Rugelach

Rugelach with Nutella

$10.99

Rugelach with Nutella

Ricotta Cookies

Soft vanilla ricotta cookies

$8.99

 Ricotta Cookies

Special cakes require at least 72 hours (3 days) notice

Special occasion orders must be placed 2 months in advance (pickup time arranged when ordering)

Address

1518 Walnut Street

Erie, PA 16502

Contact

Opening Hours

Orders due: Wednesday by 11:00 AM
Pickup: Friday, 2:00–5:00 PM

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram

Subscribe to our newsletter for some sweet stuff

© 2026 Nonna's Hearth. All rights Reserved.

bottom of page