top of page

Order Online

Accepting Orders
Pickup time: Nov 20, 2:00 PM - 5:00 PM
Pickup Address: 453 West 16th Street, Erie, PA 16502-1702

Cookies

Italian Almond Cookies

Almond flour cookies

$11.99

Italian Almond Cookies

Italian Almond Tea Cakes

Description

$20.99

Italian Almond Tea Cakes

Italian Knots

Iced Italian knot cookies with sprinkles

$9.99

Italian Knots

Ricotta Cheese Pie

Traditional Easter dessert made with Ricotta cheese, eggs, sugar, vanilla.

$21.99

Ricotta Cheese Pie

Fig-filled Knots

Fig/nut filled knot cookies

$17.50

Fig-filled Knots

Ricotta Cookies

Soft vanilla ricotta cookies

$8.99

Ricotta Cookies

White Wine Cookies

Egg-free wine cookies

$8.99

 White Wine Cookies

Biscotti - Cappuccino

Espresso biscotti

$10.99

Biscotti - Cappuccino

Biscotti - Anise

Classic anise biscotti

$12.99

Biscotti - Anise

Biscotti - Chocolate Cherry

Biscotti with chocolate, cherry, orange peel

$7.99

Biscotti - Chocolate Cherry

Pizzelles

Thin crisp cookies

$6.99

 Pizzelles
Featured

Peach cookies

Two basic dough cookies with a peach jam filling, dipped in liquor and rolled in sugar. They are topped off with a peach leaf making them look like you just picked it from a peach tree.

$21.50

Peach cookies
Featured

Lemon Cookies

Two basic dough cookies with a cream cheese/lemon curd filling, dipped in liquor and rolled in sugar. Topped off with a leaf to make a beautiful lemon!

$0.00

Lemon Cookies

Cakes

Italian Love Cake

Lemon or chocolate

$34.99

 Italian Love Cake

Apple Cake

Classic apple cake

$34.99

 Apple Cake

Lemon Loaf

Lemon loaf cake

$6.99

Lemon Loaf

Rum Cake

A Double layer sponge cake with Espresso & Rum drizzled on each layer.  Three layers (2 vanilla & 1 chocolate) of homemade pastry cream.  Frosted with a non-dairy frosting.

$69.99

Rum Cake

Peanut Butter Pie

$16.99

 Peanut Butter Pie

Nutella Pie

$16.99

Nutella Pie

Gluten Free

Apple Cake (GF/DF/SF)

Apple cake dietary-friendly

$14.99

 Apple Cake (GF/DF/SF)

Protein Balls

Energy snacks Batch (approximately 12-15)

$20.99

 Protein Balls

White Wine Cookies

$8.99

 White Wine Cookies

Amaretti

Almond cookies

$11.99

Amaretti

Seasonal

Ricotta Pie

Traditional pie

$21.99

 Ricotta Pie

Nut Rolls

$11.99

Nut Rolls

Weekly Menu

Italian Almond Cookies

Almond flour cookies

$11.99

Italian Almond Cookies

Italian Love Cake

Lemon or chocolate

$34.99

 Italian Love Cake

Nutella Pie

$16.99

Nutella Pie

Wedding/Specials

Cookies are sold in boxes of 12 dozen, which serves 50 people for $120 per box. It is recommended to choose 3-4 kinds from the list.

Cookie Box

Serves 50 people

$119.99

Italian Knots

Iced Italian knot cookies with sprinkles

$9.99

Italian Knots

Fig-filled Knots

Fig/nut filled knot cookies

$17.50

 Fig-filled Knots

Biscotti - Cappuccino

Espresso biscotti

$10.99

 Biscotti - Cappuccino

Biscotti - Anise

Classic anise biscotti

$12.99

 Biscotti - Anise

Biscotti - Chocolate Cherry

Biscotti with chocolate, cherry, orange peel

$7.99

 Biscotti - Chocolate Cherry

Fried Bow Ties

Fried dough with powdered sugar

$6.50

 Fried Bow Ties

Amaretti

Almond cookies

$11.99

 Amaretti

Rugelach

$9.99

Rugelach

Rugelach with Nutella

$10.99

Rugelach with Nutella

Ricotta Cookies

Soft vanilla ricotta cookies

$8.99

 Ricotta Cookies

Fall and Thanksgiving Sweet Treats

Fall 2026 Menu

No items to show yet

Check back soon for new items.

Christmas

No items to show yet

Check back soon for new items.

Special cakes require at least 72 hours (3 days) notice

Special occasion orders must be placed 2 months in advance (pickup time arranged when ordering)

Address

1518 Walnut Street

Erie, PA 16502

Contact

Opening Hours

Orders due: Wednesday by 11:00 AM
Pickup: Friday, 2:00–5:00 PM

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram

Subscribe to our newsletter for some sweet stuff

© 2026 Nonna's Hearth. All rights Reserved.

bottom of page